
Below is my three-minute testimony before the Delta Stewardship Council on May 25. I was the last one to make public comment at the meeting. Unfortunately, many residents of the South Delta community of Discovery Bay were unable to speak during the public comment period because their chartered bus had to leave at around 5:00 pm. In addition, many people there said DSC Chairman Randy Fiorini was rude and condescending in his treatment of several speakers.
After covering fish, water, and environmental justice issues in California and the West for over 30 years as an investigative journalist, I’ve concluded that the California Water Fix, AKA dual conveyance, is the most environmentally devastating public works project I've ever encountered. I urge the Delta Stewardship Council to reject making dual conveyance the preferred conveyance alternative in the amendments to the Delta Plan.
In my reporting, I’ve covered many aspects of the controversial plan. These include:
-
How the project won’t create one drop of new water while spending up to $67 billion of taxpayer and ratepayer’s money.
-
How the project’s former point man Jerry Meral, in a moment of candor in 2013, claimed the Delta cannot be saved, after years of promoting the peripheral canal and tunnels as the solution to the co-equal goals of water supply reliability and ecosystem restoration.
-
How scientific reviews, ranging from those of the Delta Independence Science Board, to those of federal EPA scientists, to the latest report on the California WaterFix EIS by NOAA scientists, have given the alleged science of the tunnels project a failing grade.
-
How the project won’t help Californians fund innovative water conservation, storm water capture, or water recycling projects that are desperately needed.
-
How the plan will push endangered fish species, such as Delta and longfin smelt, winter Chinook salmon, Central Valley steelhead and green sturgeon, over the abyss of extinction, while failing to address the state's long-term water supply needs.
-
How the project will devastate not only San Francisco Bay and Delta fisheries, but recreational, commercial and subsistence fisheries up and down the West Coast; the salmon fishery alone is worth $1.5 billion.