
Sugar Pine Reservoir, a beautiful mid-elevation American River watershed lake located north of Foresthill, is most renowned for its rainbow trout fishing, but it also offers sleeper fishing for smallmouth, largemouth and spotted bass, channel catfish and sunfish.
While the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) plants rainbow trout in the lake in the spring and fall, browns are exceeding rare in the catches at Sugar Pine Reservoir. The CDFW last stocked the reservoir with catchable browns in the 1990s.
Sugar Pine is one of the favorite lakes for Cal Kellogg, Fish Sniffer Editor, to fish, but he’s never caught a brown, though he’s landed lots of rainbows and some bass.
“I’ve spent hundreds of hours on this lake,” said Kellogg. “The biggest rainbow trout I’ve ever seen caught here was a 22 inch rainbow that my wife, Gena, hooked on the second ever date with me 23 years ago,” said Kellogg as we fished the reservoir on an unusually warm winter day. “She caught the fish right off the point that we’re fishing.”
“The largest – and only brown - I’ve heard of was a 5 pounder caught by Olin Bycroft of Foresthill, but browns are pretty rare here. Sugar Pine fishes best during the spring,” said Kellogg.
About 15 minutes later after Kellogg said that, a guy walked down the water and quipped, “I was going to shoot you, but I decided not to. Have you caught anything?”
“No, there’s fish surfacing off shore, but they’re not biting our offerings,” said Kellogg.
“Hey Dan,” Kellogg said to me, “this is Olin, the guy who caught that brown I was telling you about.”
I reached out and shook Olin’s hand, and quipped, “I’m honored to meet the lake brown trout record holder.”