
By Mike McNeilly
There are a lot of qualities that make a gamefish a great gamefish; a fish that's a cut above the rest. Beauty, difficulty to catch, table fare, availability and the environment the fish calls home come to mind. However, there may be an attribute above all the rest, and that is how hard the fish fights. The real brawlers usually live in saltwater. Tuna and marlin are synonymous with epic battles. Freshwater fish don't get as big, and they don't have the endurance, but some of them can really scrap.
In the lowest bracket are the wet towel fish that come in like a rotten log once hooked. A few underwhelming species that come to mind are Sacramento pikeminnow and walleye. The pikeminnow hits like a freight train and then comes placidly to hand. The walleye never does much of anything. Its fight is typically dead weight. Only the walleye's delicious flesh keeps it in high esteem amongst anglers.
Moving up the scale are diminutive fish like kokanee salmon. They fight hard pound for pound, but they usually weigh in in the ounces. How hard can a 12-ounce fish possibly fight? Plus, their mouths are as durable as wet toilet paper, so there is no way you are going to pull too hard on them. Bluegill and other sunfishes are also in this category. All the diminutive and colorful little fellows in this genus pull hard, but once again, they weigh mere ounces. If bluegill commonly weighed several pounds, they would garner a lot more respect from anglers.
Then there are the catfishes. Bullheads find themselves in the same category as pikeminnow and walleye. The typical bullhead fight is the fish trying to alligator roll while the enthusiastic angler quickly reels it to the bank. 2-4-pound channel catfish aren't much better. Once a catfish gets in the 7+ pound range, it can give a decent account.