
Spicer Reservoir, located on the North Fork of the Stanislaus River, is unique among Central Sierra Nevada reservoirs as it offers anglers a chance to catch square-tailed rainbows grown out from fingerlings or naturally spawned in Hobart Creek, the lake's main tributary.
The rainbow trout fishery has significantly improved after recovering from a tapeworm infestation that affected the lake’s fish in the late 1990s.
When the lake first filled in 1990, the influx of nutrients into the reservoir created a rich food chain, allowing rainbows to grow to large sizes, including fish in the 3 to 5 pound class. However, over recent years, the lake’s nutrients have declined, resulting in smaller, yet still healthy fish.
The Department of Fish and Wildlife stocks the reservoir with 50,000 rainbow trout fingerlings each year, a mix of Eagle Lake-strain rainbows and Kamloops trout.
Every spring, large numbers of rainbows migrate into Hobart Creek, located near the boat ramp, to spawn. To protect the naturally spawning population, fishing in the creek is closed each year until July 1.
Wild brook trout, brown trout, and brown bullhead catfish are also available, but 99 percent of the fish caught at the lake are rainbows, according to Bill Reynolds at Ebbetts Pass Sporting Goods.
Located at an elevation of 6,620 feet in the Stanislaus National Forest, Spicer straddles the border between Tuolumne County and Alpine County. The reservoir is situated on Highland Creek, a tributary of the North Fork of the Stanislaus River. The recreation area is 8 miles southwest of Highway 4 on Spicer Reservoir Road, about a 45-minute drive from Arnold.